Points don't go as far as you think. It took me 8+ years of hoarding all of my Northwest, Delta and Continental miles to earn enough for 2 roundtrip tickets to Orlando. I could have bought those same tickets for $400 each. Collecting all these points effectively adds between $400 and $600 PER YEAR to my salary. There is no comparison. Your argument is irrelevant....How about the points you get from the hotel reward programs you have. Did he stay in any hotels that you couldn't have stayed in for free with the amount of points you've earned that the company paid for?