I'd rather get a tan than frostbite!
But seriously, you should look at this long term. AE is someplace that you could be comfortable at for a real long time. With time you'll have the choice of equipment and bases. The contract is bound to be renegotiated and you have pass benies on AA. You'll probably sit right seat for 5+ years, but at least it's with large, solid company.
SYX is not something that gets even close to being livable. One base, two aircraft, and brand new contract that is still not close to where we need to be with compensation. AND we could be gone with the wind if the economy sneezes.
Do yourself a favor and get in with Eagle. Do your time, bid ORD and eventually you'll be closer to home. Don't get me wrong SYX has the best pilot group in the industry, but that doesn't keep food on the table. We have senior Captains leaving for Comair/CHQ/etc., take that for what its worth. Good luck.
Kansan