Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Friendliest aviation Ccmmunity on the web
  • Modern site for PC's, Phones, Tablets - no 3rd party apps required
  • Ask questions, help others, promote aviation
  • Share the passion for aviation
  • Invite everyone to Flightinfo.com and let's have fun

Comair NOT for sale

Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Modern secure site, no 3rd party apps required
  • Invite your friends
  • Share the passion of aviation
  • Friendliest aviation community on the web

~~~^~~~

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 21, 2001
Posts
6,137
Comair not for sale to SkyWest

By James Pilcher
Enquirer staff writer




ERLANGER – Delta Air Lines is not discussing the sale of its Erlanger-based subsidiary Comair with regional airline SkyWest, Comair’s top executive said today.

“This is a fact-based situation, and there are no discussions going on,” said Comair president Fred Buttrell in an interview. “I can’t speak for any other Delta assets, but as this applies to Comair, the possibility of us being sold to SkyWest is something that just has not come up.”

Buttrell, who took over the job in late January after running Delta’s regional network in Atlanta, was responding to comments by SkyWest chief financial officer Bradford Rich on Monday.

During a presentation at the Raymond James Institutional Investor Conference in Orlando, Fla., Rich indicated the Utah-based airline was in talks with Delta to buy Comair, fellow Delta subsidiary Atlantic Southeast Airlines or both.

“We have had some discussion with Delta about this … They have expressed their desire pretty specifically to us, and we know what they’re thinking,” Rich said. “We think we’re in the best position of anyone to take advantage of this type of an opportunity.”

Rich did not specify whether Delta was considering selling Comair or ASA or both, and indicated that the talks were preliminary. He also said that an early rough estimate indicated that SkyWest could cut either airline’s operating costs by 5 percent.

“They have in some ways suddenly and in other ways not so suddenly expressed interest in liquidating or monetizing two very significant assets,” Rich said during the conference. “We know that they have this interest. And by the way, this is more than just an interest today. As you look at Delta and what their capital requirements will be over the next year, they need to generate some capital somewhere, and this is one way of doing that.”

SkyWest, which contracts with Delta and United Airlines to provide feed to western hubs, is one of the most profitable airlines in the regional industry and has more than $500 million in available cash. Its stock rose 16 cents to $18.05 this afternoon on the news of Rich’s comments. SkyWest officials did not immediately comment.

Delta has lost more than $7 billion in the past four years, and narrowly avoided a bankruptcy filing last fall. Its stock rose 3 cents to $5.30 in mid-afternoon trading today.

The Atlanta-based airline took a $1.9 billion charge associated with the write down in value of both Comair and ASA last quarter. Delta, the nation’s third-largest airline, bought Comair for $2.3 billion in January 2000.

Comair now employs more than 6,000, including 4,000 locally at the Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky International Airport, where it operates the most flights of any airline, providing feed to Delta’s second-largest hub.

Delta purchased Atlanta-based ASA for $1 billion the previous year. Since then, problems have arisen at both carriers, with Comair’s pilots conducting an 89-day strike in spring 2001 and ASA suffering from significant operational issues with on-time performance.

Delta spokesman John Kennedy would not comment on either whether the airline was discussing selling off one or both of its regional subsidiaries, nor would he address Rich’s comments.

In December, however, Delta chief executive officer Gerald Grinstein publicly discussed the possibility of spinning off or selling Comair or ASA, saying that Delta could get the same benefit from the regional carriers without owning them. He did not indicate that any talks were underway at the time, or whether Delta intended to make Comair independent once more.

Industry expert Mike Miller said that a sale of Comair or ASA or both could make sense for both Delta and SkyWest.

“SkyWest is known as a very efficient operator, and they could get a very good economy of scale by consolidating the three operations into one,” said Miller, co-partner in The Velocity Group, a Washington, D.C.-based aviation consulting firm. “And for Delta, not only would they get the cash, but this would enable them to get really aggressive and competitive with the rates they pay their regional providers, which they can’t really do now since they own two of them.”

But Buttrell said that if such talks were actually underway, he would be required to sign a confidentiality agreement, and that none of the steps normally taken during such a process were underway.

“Delta has not even asked us to start completing due diligence, which would be part of any possible deal,” Buttrell said.

E-mail [email protected]
 
Well, there you go. No more Helena for Comair pilots.



Bye Bye--General Lee
 
Let's see.. Delta stock at $5.30. How many shares are on the market? Delta employees bought a 767.... I think the Comair employees should buy 50.1% of Delta.
 
So Fred claims he hasn't been consulted. Yeah right. Fred still has more work to do extracting concessions from the mechanics and F/As. Talk of selling them to Skywest certainly doesn't make that job easier. The CMR pilots folded quickly when a shiny new E170 perfomed its dog and pony show on the CMR ramp, but the other employee groups have been more problematic.

Without a doubt Delta is soliciting for a buyer, my guess is Skywest is looking to see what they want and Chq and Mesa are doing the same.

Rich said SkyWest has "had some discussions with Delta about [the sale]." He noted that Delta "has expressed their desire pretty specifically to us...We are aware of their interest, and we are looking at this."
 
chperplt said:
Let's see.. Delta stock at $5.30. How many shares are on the market? Delta employees bought a 767.... I think the Comair employees should buy 50.1% of Delta.

Do it, and then you can have 50.1% of the debt. Go for it! Then you can make sure you have a choice of Helena layovers....(and, you can elect me--General LEE----defacto CEO and Czar of morale!---but, I will need 400,000 options and my own CRJ painted orange)


Bye Bye--General Lee
 
False Alarm?

I cant imagine Delta only getting 500 mil for one of the carriers, let alone two. I also cant imagine Skywest spending all of their available capital (500 Mil) to acquire one or both of the airlines. This puts Skywest in a bad position as well as increases Delta's DCI costs immediately.

If this is just a silly rumor, is it possible to increase our successorship protection incase it happens again? Just a thought.
 
Tim47SIP said:
I cant imagine Delta only getting 500 mil for one of the carriers, let alone two. I also cant imagine Skywest spending all of their available capital (500 Mil) to acquire one or both of the airlines. This puts Skywest in a bad position as well as increases Delta's DCI costs immediately.

If this is just a silly rumor, is it possible to increase our successorship protection incase it happens again? Just a thought.

While I do believe it is nothing more than a rumor and posturing by Skywest's CEO, companies typically do not buy other companies strictly with cash. Debt and stock typically makes up a large portion of how a company finances these types of transactions.

-Neal
 
Personally, I find it interesting that Fred Buttrell would come out and immediately quell speculation by stating that Comair is not for sale, while the best ASA management can muster is the standard "Due to Federal Trade Commission regulations we cannot speculate blah blah blah..." nonsense. Makes me think that perhaps we (ASA) are the target.
 
FmrFreightDog said:
Personally, I find it interesting that Fred Buttrell would come out and immediately quell speculation by stating that Comair is not for sale, while the best ASA management can muster is the standard "Due to Federal Trade Commission regulations we cannot speculate blah blah blah..." nonsense. Makes me think that perhaps we (ASA) are the target.

We could only hope to be so lucky.
 
See--this is what happens when you live between nuc and cw testing areas and deprive yourself of alcohol and premarital companionship. Silly, halucinating mormons; think you can buy airlines that aren't for sale!

(Ducks as Joe Smith's golden plates come flying at my head)
 
IF SkyWest WANTED to buy Comair or ASA, they would be for sale. Dont fool yourselves. Big D is getting nervous with the rising fuel costs and could really use some cash from anyone.
 
Cash for DAL is merely a bandaid for a gunshot wound.
 
FmrFreightDog said:
Personally, I find it interesting that Fred Buttrell would come out and immediately quell speculation by stating that Comair is not for sale, while the best ASA management can muster is the standard "Due to Federal Trade Commission regulations we cannot speculate blah blah blah..." nonsense. Makes me think that perhaps we (ASA) are the target.


Wonder if Willie would be part of the deal?

:)
 
Palerider957 said:
Cash for DAL is merely a bandaid for a gunshot wound.

What? We haven't changed anything in our operations and are just bleeding to death? Where have you been? No, our management wants to get rid of some assets and then they will whipsaw you guys for fun. Sad but true. But, extra cash would help with the fuel prices, or NW sticking with the fare increase, which it said it would.

Here is a quote from good ole Ray Neidl today:

"I don't think Delta is up against the wall at this point, but the extra liquidity sure would help," said Ray Neidl, analyst for Calyon Securities in New York.

Careful, your general nervousness is showing.


Bye Bye--General Lee
 
Last edited:
Inconceivable said:
See--this is what happens when you live between nuc and cw testing areas and deprive yourself of alcohol and premarital companionship. Silly, halucinating mormons; think you can buy airlines that aren't for sale!

(Ducks as Joe Smith's golden plates come flying at my head)

I'm curious.....If Robert Johnson were to throw his hat in the ring if
you'd call him a hallucinating Black man? What about Carl Icahn?
Bad choice for someone buying an airline, but would you call him
a hallucinating Jew? I'm not sure I understand why this topic has
to degrade to the point of ignorant remarks like this.
 
Source: Aviation Daily 3.8.05

SkyWest CEO Jerry Atkin yesterday sought to cool widespread speculation that the carrier is considering buying Delta's regional subsidiaries, Atlantic Southeast (ASA) and Comair.

Atkin told The DAILY at the International Society of Transport Aircraft Trading (ISTAT) conference in Scottsdale, Ariz., that recent press reports about purchase negotiations with Delta were a stretch. "We've had solicited and unsolicited discussions with every network carrier in America -- anything beyond that is speculation," Atkin said. He later echoed that point in a presentation, saying, "There are some opportunities out there, and when we get beyond the exploratory phase, we'll talk about it."

SkyWest in the past two years has been open about its desire to use its robust balance sheet -- now at about $500 million in cash and marketable securities -- for acquisitions. It's not the first time SkyWest has eyed buying another regional carrier. The airline considered buying ExpressJet before Continental decided to spin off its regional arm.

Speculation about the Delta subsidiaries stemmed from comments by SkyWest CFO Bradford Rich at the Raymond James investor conference in Orlando on Monday. Rich said SkyWest has "had some discussions with Delta about [the sale]." He noted that Delta "has expressed their desire pretty specifically to us...We are aware of their interest, and we are looking at this."

Rich also said, however, that SkyWest is "not interested in growth for growth's sake" and that the carrier would move very carefully if it decided to pursue the Delta acquisition. "A number of issues would have to be worked out and dealt with," Rich said. Because of its strong cash position, SkyWest is "in the best position of anyone to take advantage" of this type of opportunity.

Analyst Robert Mann, of RW Mann and Co., told The DAILY that "it is easy to understand Delta's desire to monetize the regional carrier assets...to raise cash and offload debt and obligations." But he noted that Comair and ASA are among the highest-cost regional carriers in the industry, "and thus will not fetch the sort of financial multiples that ExpressJet, Pinnacle and Republic Airline Holdings have achieved."

This might result in a low purchase price and the appearance of a good deal for SkyWest or another buyer, although the subsidiaries would come with a significant "fix-up" price tag and high labor costs, Mann said. Delta would also face the issue of losing control of its regional flying.

Also at the ISTAT conference, Atkin said he finds Bombardier's proposed C- Series plane intriguing, and believes the unit costs of the 110- to 130-seat aircraft family could be attractive if the Canadian airframer launches the larger jets.

Atkin said SkyWest has looked at the plane and found its unit costs were "below anything out there in that size." He noted it's not clear how SkyWest might use the aircraft in today's marketplace but "we have a couple years to figure that out." Bombardier's board this month is scheduled to decide whether to launch the plane.

One of the many options SkyWest has considered for the future is operating planes up to 150 seats as a low-cost operator. It also looked at opportunities to partner with existing low-cost airlines. Like the scenario at many regional carriers, SkyWest's deliveries are murky beyond 2005. The carrier has no firm deliveries planned after June, but Atkin said there's been a lot discussion with his carrier's major partners and other carriers about future growth.
 

Latest resources

Back
Top Bottom