OK OK OK.
I'm tired of all this Colgan bashing. It's very simple really.
Colgan Air is an airline like any other, and a company like any other. They all have issues. Some employees love it, some hate it, some just don't care. But Colgan is good for some things.
Personally, I am quite happy to be at Colgan. It's not that bad. I don't necessarily mean to defend this company, but I wish to provide some of my personal input, so please excuse the rant. Feel free to tear it apart as you please, I don't really care.
1

Fast upgrade. The only that counts in this industry is TURBINE PIC time. You can have all the SIC Jet you want, it won't count for sh!t other than your total time. Ask all the old farts you want, that's what they all say. Majors love commuter pilots cuz they know we work harder than most.
2

Pay isn't that great, but we are the highest paid Beech pilots in the country. All companies make pay mistakes sometimes. It happens, get over it. Yeah yeah so you make more second year flying an RJ, fine. But at Colgan you're upgrading to captain. Also, if they call you on a day off, then DONT ANSWER THE PHONE. It's that easy.
3

You get to actually be a pilot, not a system monitor, or a switch flicker, or computer programmer. I know some are more interested in the instant gratification that an air conditioned jet and the QOL that can sometimes go along with that. But that ain't fer me right now. I'll go for QOL when I'm sitting in a 737 or 717 or whatever bigger stuff might come along.
4

My personal QOL here is great however. I get about 12 to 14 days off, fly about 95 hours a month, and my commute home is a one legger with Southwest. ONCE AGAIN, I realize that it is not always so perfect for everyone.
5

About maintenance. Colgan can be pretty dumb about some of their logistics, it's true. However, the airplanes are not only 20 years old, but ridden hard and put away wet. I'm actually surprised things aren't broken more often. Sure I've seen 6 stupid MELs, or even some stuff not get fixed coming out of a maintenance base. It's not that big a deal.
Finally, I realize Colgan is far from perfect. Sure I'd love to have a working VCM all the time, and not bother with st00pid pressurization issues, or whatever else can be thrown at you, but that's part of the deal that comes with Colgan. At least it's Turbine time, a quick upgrade, and HIGH-QUALITY time at that.
Colgan is to be take for what it is, nothing more. It's a steppping stone, not a career company.