Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Friendliest aviation Ccmmunity on the web
  • Modern site for PC's, Phones, Tablets - no 3rd party apps required
  • Ask questions, help others, promote aviation
  • Share the passion for aviation
  • Invite everyone to Flightinfo.com and let's have fun

Cheat river fly-in landing accident (Fall 2024)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Neal
  • Start date Start date
  • Watchers Watchers 3

Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Modern secure site, no 3rd party apps required
  • Invite your friends
  • Share the passion of aviation
  • Friendliest aviation community on the web

Neal

Forums Chief Pilot
Staff member
Joined
Oct 31, 1996
Posts
1,166
Type aircraft owned
Carbon Cub FX-3
Base airport
KFCI
Ratings
COMM, IFR, MEL, SEL
Better video of this I saw on Facebook but here is a YouTube video of it (same video). Maule had a bad landing and took out two parked planes in the process of finding the trees. Very sad especially on a stunning gorgeous day at a great event. I was planning to go to this event but other obligations kept me closer to home so I went to a different fly-in lunch event.

 
A good reminder to alway pay attention near a flight line.
 
I planned to attend that one too but other obligations intervened. The PA-11 belongs to a friend of mine from Ohio.

That is not a particularly difficult airport to get into, but the narrow valley it's in and consequent adjustment to the landing pattern makes less experienced pilots uncomfortable. It is possible to make a steep straight-in approach to runway 31 over trees on higher terrain, but it is easier and safer to make a slightly curved final approach over the river. This also spooks less experienced pilots.

Watching the video, the pilot had the airplane in a good position over the threshold if just slightly fast. The problem may have been initiated by being undecided whether to do a three point or a wheel landing. This is always a set-up for problems, because the resulting arrival often results in a bounced landing. However, the bounce itself does not automatically result in a loss of directional control. While the airplane started into a ground loop, the entry was not violent and was certainly recoverable. If you watch the flight controls on the Maule as the accident progressed, you can see very little input was used to correct the left swerve. It may be that the pilot was a bit overwhelmed to start with and the situation deteriorated faster that he or she could keep up with. Somewhere in there, they transitioned from being a pilot to a passenger.

Tsquared brings up a very good point. I often see people standing very near a runway pay no attention to arriving or departing aircraft. I have watched the sporty results of a blown tire or loss of control on the runway on several occasions.
 
Note to self: When parking at events, get as close to the tree line as possible. While it's not the Cessna's fault, it does catch my attention how far out it is compared to others. It seems when the pilot goosed the power just prior to touchdown they were in a landing recovery mode at that point and directional control became secondary.
 
It occurred to me, that we should also expect that attending events like this is going to result in someone filming your landing, departures and any other movements. Plan accordingly.
 
I completely missed the fact that what initiated the swerve in the Maule was the collision with the vertical stabilizer and rudder of a Cessna 182. I didn't notice that when first viewing the video.

Some of my previous comments still relate, but loss of control was initiated by the first collision with the Cessna, not pilot inattention.

Have to hand it to the Maule pilot, though; not everyone can wreck three airplanes at once.
 
This has the potential to get ugly for the host when the FAA/NTSB steps in, if they do I'm afraid. I hope I'm wrong and it just gets handled by insurance and it's done with. Lawyers won't help either if they get involved.
 

Latest resources

Back
Top