scabseeker said:
TonyC, tell me you are not in favor of us flying point to point in Canada. Or do you think we can have cabotage in Canada without the reciprocal here?
I said it was ironic, not wrong or right. I'd say the average citizen is under the false impression that NAFTA would allow anybody to go anywhere in North America - - such is not the case.
I'm in fact not up to speed on which of the freedoms are permitted in Canada. The consolidation of freight in gateways might be, in fact, a matter of expediency rather than international law. We might be permitted to fly FedEx freight from point A in Canada, stop at point B in Canada, drop off NO freight but pick up more, and then continue to Memphis - - I simply don't know. I DO know that a Canadian company (Morning Star) operates FedEx logoed 727's within Canada.
As for cabotage in the US -- it's already legal, thanks to Senator Ted Stevens, R-AK. As of now it's restricted to freight, and only through Anchorage, but it's the proverbial foot in the door. A foreign carrier can pick up US-origined freight in Anchorage and carry it to any other point in the US. Ain't that special.
Back to your question, though... Yeah, I think we ought to be able to fly point to point in Canada and do whatever we please, and they shouldn't be able to cross the border for any reason whatsoever.

Selfish, huh?
No, seriously. I think we ought to be able to make as many stops as we please so long as all the freight goes through the US -- no picking up in Canada and dropping off someplace else in Canada along the way. (I don't have my handy, dandy Five Freedoms reference card handy, and I don't recall which one of them I just described, but you can discern the intent nonetheless.)