I spent 5 years at ASA, and my wife still works for ASA. To answer your question, you will be much happier at NJ than at ASA. You will make more money, have a better schedule, be treated much better by the company and all its employees. You are a valued member of a team, not a replaceable blue collar number.
Your medical, dental, life, supplemental life, vision, etc. is the best in all of aviation, including the majors.
You will not miss jumpseating or nonreving at all.. as you are automatically Hilton Honors Diamond level when you step foot on property day one indoc. I have been with the company about 5 months, and I already have enough Delta skymiles to go anywhere in the world roundtrip....and stay at a hilton resort while I am there! POSITIVE SPACE
When I worked at ASA, I got to the point where I felt like the guy in the Dunken Donuts commercial.. "time to make the donuts". You drive to the parking lot, get on the same tired old bus with Atlantas finest driving you... You duty in, check your v file, go find your airplane, pull your hair out trying to get aircraft services (lav, catering, gate agent) finally board your pissed off pax. Fly 5 legs to the same cities for 4 days. Stay in dumpy hotels for the most part.. the hotel staff treats you like a "regional" pilot.. you are not good enough to be in their hotel. Get reduced rest multiple times for someone elses F___Up (usually scheduling, or the gate). Then you get the company (ASA) to send out an announcement that they are taking VOLUNTEERS to come out at midnight and clean the airplanes uncompensated... This after you are routinely told by managment that you are not worth the paper that money is printed on.
You now get to come home and do a jepp revision that looks like the encylcopedia britanica, and hear CNN report on how HORRIBLE the airline you work for is and that your company is the worst ontime, lost baggage and pax complaint airline of all time for the longest running consecutive period in aviation history.
Then you go online and look at your checking account and wonder why you became a pilot in the first place. It was a passion when I started, but now I am 100,000 dollars in debt and living off of credit cards because my paycheck every two weeks is less than $1000 pre tax.
Life at NJ... you are told by mangament that you are doing a great job all the time, you are compensated for everything you do, including Jepp revisions. When you show up for work you might be going to the west cost, you might be going to mexico, you might be going to sit in Hilton Conrad in downtown miami for 3 days. Either way there is nothing monotonous about go to work.. You get to choose to work 26 weeks a year... Best part time job for full time pay in the world! Your pax want to be there... they are interesting and friendly for the most part. I guess the bottom line is that NJ flying makes aviation fun agian.. and you can support your family doing it, and you have unparalleled job security!