• NC Software is proud to announce the release of APDL - Airline Pilot Logbook version 10.0. Click here to view APDL on the Apple App store and install now.
  • Logbook Pro for Apple iOS version 8.1 is now available on the App Store. Major update including signature endorsements and dark/light theme support. Click here to install now.

Aloha Airlines to ask court to throw out union contracts

Sep 1, 2004
Total Time
By Dave Segal

Aloha Airlines, which earlier this year won concessions from each of its five labor groups, wants to ratchet up the pressure on its unions for more givebacks.

The bankrupt carrier said it intends to file a motion as early as today seeking court approval to reject collective-bargaining agreements with its unions and terminate their defined-benefit pension plans. Aloha plans to seek a new contract with more work-rule changes for its unionized employees, but no additional pay cuts.

The company has requested hearings in bankruptcy court on Oct. 28 and 31.
"We're optimistic we'll reach consensual agreement with our employee groups (before the hearing)," said David Banmiller, Aloha's chief executive and president.

Former Aloha pilot Steve Brenessel, who went on medical retirement in early January, called Aloha's move "outrageous" and said the pilots were going to fight it "every inch of the way."

"That was a totally unexpected filing," he said. "They had said they wanted to negotiate with the pilots and almost simultaneously they went to the court and filed it. (The pilots) used the analogy of being in a prison camp where the guard says, 'If you try to escape you'll be shot, but meanwhile I want to tell you you'll be executed in the morning.'"

Separately, financially strapped Aloha is to receive a $1.3 million payment to cover about half of the $2.5 million the carrier has said it is owed by now-defunct ground tour and transportation company Trans Hawaiian Services. Trans Hawaiian was bought in 2000 by its local competitor, Roberts Hawaii, then filed bankruptcy. Aloha was one of Trans Hawaiian's biggest creditors.

Aloha, which is aiming to leave Chapter 11 reorganization before the end of this year, has said one of the conditions of its new Los Angeles-based investors is that its unions' pension plans be terminated. Airlines around the country have been seeking to replace their workers' defined-benefit pensions with defined-contribution plans.

Aloha, which filed for bankruptcy at the end of last year, won concessions earlier this year from its pilots, flight attendants, mechanics, clerical workers and dispatchers, including 10 percent pay cuts and work-rule changes. The concessions also included the forgiveness of additional 10 percent wage snapbacks that the unions had agreed to after 9/11. In addition, the unions gave up 2 percent pay increases that they were due.

If the pension plans are terminated, affected employees would receive benefits -- some of them reduced -- by the federal agency that insures pensions. All of Aloha's unions except the Association of Flight Attendants have defined-benefit plans.

Brenessel, the former pilot, called the situation the "biggest crisis the pilots have ever faced" and said the company promised in negotiations earlier this year it wouldn't take such an action.

"If we don't accept their rules, there will be total radical destruction of the pilots' work rules, compensation, hourly pay, number of flight hours, pension plans, medical insurance, everything that's covered in the contract. ... It's a complete destruction of the whole structure of the relationship between management and employees," Brenessel said.


Adult Swim junkie
Jul 16, 2002
Total Time
Not like any "regional" I know...

Equipment: 737s

Routes: transpacific (Hawaii to mainland), and inter-island.

Nothing "regional" about their pay either. As regards the above article: How many regionals do you know that provide a pension?

And my ultimate "regional" common-sense litmus test: Regional airlines feed Mainline, Mainline airlines get fed passengers by their regional affiliates.

Oh well, nevermind. I guess its not important anyway...
Last edited:


Well-known member
Nov 26, 2001
Total Time
Rogue5 said:
Not like any "regional" I know...

Equipment: 737s

Routes: transpacific (Hawaii to mainland), and inter-island.

Nothing "regional" about their pay either.

Oh well, nevermind. I guess its not important anyway...

Well, ACTUALLY....

There are some regional routes (the interisland stuff), and, after this next round with Judge Faris, you can bet the pay and retirement will be regional level. And, forget about the A plan.

Either way, it's tragic what's happening over there. Very sad. I wish I hadn't predicted it.


Registered Abuser
Mar 4, 2002
Total Time
FlamingFUPA said:
Because Aloha is a regional? Gosh!
Off topic, I know what is a FlamingFUPA, cool avatar!