Zoombags..
As a graduate of the Colorado School for Wayward Children, I'll say the following...
Personally, I hated the place, hated Colorado Springs, and hated Colorado in general (being from Florida...a beach only 15 minutes away on average). As I got away from the Academy, I found my hatred was all focused on the Academy, and just sort of bled over to the state. Though I wouldn't want to live in CS, Colorado itself I've been back to many times and I think it's very nice. Couldn't handle the bitter cold though. As I've gotten older, I've come up with some observations.
First of all, Albie is right to an extent, you have to remember that though it's a military academy, it's still filled with hormone overloaded teenagers...ie it's still a college in terms of general population. The kind of stuff that goes on there goes on at other colleges (look at filming porn movies on campus, Girls Gone Wild, etc). The difference is that we don't expect that kind of behavior at a military academy. Because military academies by their very nature try to produce a homogenious group, 'different' behavior only stands out more.
There are problems with this kind of setup of course. There are not the normal outlets for 'blowing off steam' that exist at a regular college. Also, students at USAFA don't learn nearly the amount of 'real world' experience that their regular college friends may learn (balancing work, school, social, etc). Also, if a person has serious control issues, the USAFA will tend to enhance them in the long run.
However, it has positive effects as well. First, you learn early to be able to laugh at the absurd. Secondly, discipline...not for you S & M types, but stuff that will help you later on. I was a prime example...high school was EASY for me, didn't study, have to work hard, etc. The USAFA changed that in a hurry, where I learned priorization, organizing, not procrastinating, etc. Finally, you make friends for life, sort of the 'shared adversity' thing. It's like a really big fraternity, talking (and complaining) how much the 'zoo' as changed, stupid cadet tricks, etc.
Of course, there are the practical benefits. Full scholarship including room, board, textbooks, meals, etc. Guaranteed job when you graduate. Fairly well rounded education. Some of the other benefits no longer exist though. All commissions are reserve now (not that I could ever figure out exactly what the difference was), and pilot slots are now order of merit based (ie just because you are medically qualified doesn't give you a pilot slot).
I think what has happened is that the pool of potental applicants has gotten smaller over time. That in combination has resulted in a 'broading of the spectrum' of criteria for qualification (casting a wider net). Personally, I think the average quality of applicant has gone down because of it. I would have been happier to have smaller class sizes but keep the same quality.
Finally, performance at the USAFA has absolutely no relavance to how a person does in the real world. One classmate of mine in particular was ALWAYS in trouble with 'the man', threatening not to graduate him one time in particular. He now is an F-15E Weapons School Instructor (last I heard) and is considered one of the best pilots in the F-15E. Heck, I graduated by the skin of my teeth (I was kind of an academic rock) but I've done okay, if not exactly spectactular.
So, what's my point? College kids do stupid stuff, no matter where they go to school. As a grad, I just laugh at it for the most part. Considering what I hear about in 'real' schools, most of it seems pretty tame in fact.
FastCargo