I'm sorry, crj567, but I gotta call a spade a spade and you are a tool.
The first month of PBS at ASA has been an overwhelming success. Sure there were some hiccups throughout the launch, but our ALPA guys worked tirelessly to fix the issues. Even the most hardcore naysayers, except you, have come around to see our PBS system for what it really is...an improvement to line bidding! <gasp> It just takes time and energy to learn the system to get the most out of it. If you are not willing to do that I'm sure everyone junior to you will appreciate it.
You are right about one thing. Pairing construction is the key to a good schedule. But that has always been the case....even with line bidding. Now you just get to pick the trips you want instead of having someone else do it for you. Who would you rather have build your schedule, YOU or Pappageorgio? Now hopefully we get some language in the next contract that allows us to have more control over the pairing construction process. But we will just have to wait and see.
Oh, and how is the coin toss thing embarrassing? This just shows me you have no idea how this process works or what it is used for. It's only used to resolve a dispute if there is one. I heard the company was happy to use ALPA's bid runs and had no issues. Of course they don't use it in court because there is a judge to rule on disputes. There is no judge or arbitrator sitting in the A-Tech waiting to rule on our bid runs. Just the company and ALPA. Would you prefer they play rock, paper, scissors? Arm wrestle?
Look, everyone who reads this board knows you hate ALPA. We get it. I have been hard on them too in the past and we need to hold their feet to the fire. But you are way off base on your anti-PBS platform. Just sit down with a trainer for a few hours and learn how to bid. Or you can continue to be miserable for the rest of your career at ASA.