Or you can go to the interview, and form your own opinions... Either way it's not a bad experience. You'll find most of the people on here that complain about Colgan, have never infact been involved with colgan.
Honestly, some hate it, some love it. Depends how the company fits you. With your flight times, it will be at least 2 years before you upgrade, even at colgan... so i wouldn't pick a place for fast upgrade. The Q will not be a fast upgrade at all. FO rates are pretty decent in the beech, ok in the saab, and crappy in the Q, but you get the same no matter which airplane you end up in. If you go to the beech, you'll end up in the saab or Q within a year, and it's not gonna be an easy few months.
The Flying at colgan is excellent experience. Down low in the wx gets you up to speed fast. Typical legs range from 30 min to 1:30, so you get to do it lots of times a day.
Before Pinnacle bought colgan, Colgan pretty much went under the radar, and did as regional was supposed to... Short feed routes to our code shares. the Q has changed things. Colgan, for now, is still partialy outstation based. Makes commuting hard some times, but, Everybody at a base gets to know eachother well, and you will develope into a small "family" Seems colganites always stick together, and are always willing to walk resume's in etc...
If you want a real feeling for the airline, go on the interview, and then afterwords, sit in the terminal and introduce yourself to colgan pilots... ask them how they like it, pro/cons etc.