Even if XJT pilots wanted to refuse recall to take advantage of the possible upgrade it will not be allowed. Per the understanding reached between ALPA, XJT, and CAL, furloughed Coex pilots taking part in this program shall resign their seniority number upon their recall to Coex.
I guess CAL and XJT don't want to go to all the trouble of keeping the furloughed pilots happy if they aren't going to come back. I think it'd be nice to have the option, although honestly I don't think too many people would forgo recall at XJT even to upgrade with CommutAir. No offense at all to CommutAir. Being an FO on reserve stinks. Being at the bottom of a 2300 pilot list stinks. But the pay, benefits, and growth potential after the first year are arguably better at XJT and, depending on what happens with the current contract negotiations, it could be substantially better even than captain pay.
I think this whole agreement is a good opportunity both for furloughed Coex pilots and for all CommutAir pilots. I haven't heard much from people on the CommutAir side of the fence. How does the average CA pilot feel about this? Hopefully, everyone understands that this isn't the ideal situation, but rather a reasonable compromise.