You just need to read some of the posts on this very thread from people that claim to have superior education.
Your reading comprehension skills are pretty atrocious. Nobody on this thread stated that they had superior education by attending a university. That claim has never been made.
Your argument that the degree would make sense if somehow related to the field of flying, while true, is also completely totally irrelevant. Half the pilots in my squadron had Art History degrees, and they flew just fine. The Legacies do not care what the degree is in, just that you have one. Argue all you want till you're blue in the face that this is stupid and pointless, and while you're correct, it won't change the fact that that's the way it is.
And as far as Yip's example, the kid who worked his way up while completing his degree online, while a fine example, is also the exception and not the rule. In my personal experiences both at the regional level, as well as my subsequent long-haul stint, the rule was always (without exception) the Captain working furiously on his degree on layovers, exhausted, because he had life responsibilities waiting for him back home. Many finally finished, but it took them many many years to do so.
Nobody claimed their knowledge is superior because they have a degree, so you can quit that argument.
Nobody argued that a non-aviation related degree is more valuable than a degree with direct relation to the job, so you can quit making that argument up too.
Nobody made the argument that "well I better go blow $120k at ERAU then!!!"
Nobody made the argument that having the degree has to have
any logic behind it. it is what it is, and has been for a long long time. When you get to head up the hiring practices at United, American or Delta, by all means please change it. But until that day, the fact remains that they require a degree,
any degree to be considered.
Arguing anything else is pointless.
To be considered for a Legacy carrier, you need a degree. Period. It's so simple even a dumb pilot can get it.
Well, most of the time.