Why are you casting insults? There's no need to be a hothead. If you have a point to make then make it politely. I will listen and respond politely. For example, I could respond by saying "at least my genetic code isn't missing several strands" but I don't want to turn this into an insult war so I won't.
Will they fire 1800 pilots? I don't know. What I do know is that if they only fire one I don't want it to be me.
I also know that just about all the guys I've spoken with plan on paying the agency shop dues after sending their letters of objection and challenge and after recieving the certified bill from USAPA. You're not gonna have 1800 pilots behind you. You're gonna be like Will Farrell on Old School when you realize you're the only person running down the street naked.
Honestly, I don't care what you do. If you want to take your chances then more power to you.
I don't think it separates the men from the boys because frankly, there haven't been any men as leaders on either side.
The west leadership simply says,"keep your chin up your eyes on the prize and await further orders."
"But sir, we have no ammunition"
"Steady boy, steady"
"For that matter sir, we have no guns"
"Stand your post"
"Sir, all we have is an empty ALPA toolbox some of the boys broke open. Well, actually it had a banana in it."
"Steady man. Don't let them see you blink"
"Sir, your inaction has reduced us to throwing poo, like some tick-infested spider monkey"
"Remain steadfast. We're working on a response"
The west pinned their hopes on ALPA defending them, which was futile. The east had little if any opposition and USAPA filled a leadership vacuum. Not with leadership, mind you, but with whatever guys were willing to accept.
Those who are willing to follow the west "leaders" (hint: you actually need to do something, not just have a plan you might someday employ, especially when so many are expecting so much) might want to take a rational look at their track record as well. They aren't advocating anything that multiplies their leverage or puts USAPA on the defensive.
In short, you're on your own. Do what makes sense to you and don't plan on getting support from anyone.